Choosing between a saltwater pool and a traditional chlorine pool is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when installing or upgrading your pool in Rhode Island. While both systems sanitize your pool water effectively, they differ significantly in maintenance needs, cost, and user experience.
This guide walks you through the pros and cons of each system so you can decide which type of pool water is the best fit for your budget, health goals, and lifestyle.
How Do Saltwater and Chlorine Pools Work?
Chlorine Pools
Chlorine pools are the most common type in Rhode Island and across the U.S. Pool owners manually add chlorine tablets, granules, or liquid to kill bacteria and algae. These chemicals are essential to maintain safe, clean water.
Saltwater Pools
Saltwater pools use a salt chlorine generator that converts salt into chlorine through electrolysis. While saltwater pools still contain chlorine, it’s produced automatically in lower, more stable amounts—creating softer water and reducing chemical handling.
Installation and Upfront Cost
Chlorine Pools
Chlorine systems are typically included in standard pool packages, making them the most affordable to install. There’s no need for additional equipment beyond a standard filtration and pump system.
Saltwater Pools
A saltwater system adds $1,500 to $2,500 to your upfront pool installation cost. That includes the generator, installation, and any necessary electrical work. Some systems may also require upgraded pool materials (such as corrosion-resistant fittings).
Bottom Line: Chlorine pools are cheaper to install. Saltwater systems involve higher upfront costs but may offset those over time through lower chemical usage.
Ongoing Maintenance and Costs
Chlorine Pools
Routine chlorine purchases and water balancing are required. Most owners spend $300 to $600 per season on chemicals, depending on pool size and usage. You’ll also need to monitor pH, alkalinity, and stabilizers regularly.
Saltwater Pools
Saltwater pools require fewer chemical adjustments, as the system continuously produces chlorine. You’ll still need to monitor water chemistry and occasionally add salt, but many owners find them easier to maintain overall.
However, salt cells must be replaced every 3 to 7 years, at a cost of $500–$800.
Bottom Line: Saltwater pools may have slightly lower annual maintenance costs and less chemical handling, but periodic equipment replacement offsets those savings.
Water Comfort and User Experience
Chlorine Pools
Chlorine pools are effective, but high concentrations can lead to strong odors, dry skin, red eyes, and faded swimsuits. Proper management minimizes these issues, but sensitive users may still notice them.
Saltwater Pools
Saltwater pools have softer water, thanks to lower chlorine levels and added salt. Most swimmers report less skin irritation and no noticeable chlorine smell. The water feels silkier and gentler on eyes and hair.
Bottom Line: Saltwater pools are preferred by families with children or anyone with sensitive skin, eyes, or allergies.
Lifespan and Equipment Durability
Chlorine Pools
With proper upkeep, chlorine systems and equipment can last a long time. However, over-chlorination can degrade liners, pool covers, and equipment faster if not carefully managed.
Saltwater Pools
Saltwater is corrosive to certain metals and finishes. If you choose this system, ensure all pool components (ladders, handrails, fixtures) are made of salt-compatible materials like resin or high-grade stainless steel. Heaters and pumps must also be rated for saltwater use.
Bottom Line: Saltwater pools require the right materials to avoid corrosion, but they’re very durable when installed properly.
Environmental Impact and Safety
Chlorine Pools
While effective, chlorine is a strong chemical. Improper storage or overuse can pose risks to pets, plants, and even swimmers. Spills must be handled carefully, and chemicals stored securely.
Saltwater Pools
Saltwater systems generate chlorine in a gentler way and involve less manual chemical handling, reducing the risk of exposure. However, discharged water can damage plants or corrode nearby surfaces if not properly managed.
Bottom Line: Saltwater pools offer a safer handling experience, but both systems require responsible water management.
Which Pool System Is Right for You?
|
Feature
|
Chlorine Pool
|
Saltwater Pool
|
|---|---|---|
|
Upfront Cost
|
Lower
|
Higher
|
|
Ongoing Costs
|
Moderate
|
Slightly Lower
|
|
Maintenance
|
Manual
|
Automated/Low Touch
|
|
Water Feel
|
Can be harsh
|
Soft/Silky
|
|
Skin Irritation
|
More common
|
Less common
|
|
Chlorine Smell
|
Noticeable
|
Minimal
|
|
Equipment Needs
|
Basic
|
Salt-compatible only
|
|
Ideal For
|
Budget-focused owners
|
Comfort and ease
|
Let Pools Plus Inc. Help You Decide
Still not sure which system is right for your Rhode Island pool? Pools Plus Inc. has decades of experience installing, maintaining, and servicing both chlorine and saltwater systems. We’ll help you:
- Evaluate your property and pool usage
- Understand system compatibility and long-term costs
- Select the right equipment for safety and performance
We also offer complete pool services and in-store support for supplies, troubleshooting, and expert advice.
Have questions? Contact us today to speak with a local pool specialist.
Conclusion
For Rhode Island homeowners, both saltwater and chlorine pools can deliver clean, safe, and enjoyable swimming experiences. The best choice depends on your budget, maintenance preferences, and how sensitive you or your family are to traditional pool chemicals.
No matter which system you choose, Pools Plus Inc. is here to support you with quality installation, reliable service, and expert guidance every step of the way.
